skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

My boyfriend and I were looking to try something new. It was our first time at Timothy’s and we were not disappointed! We received warm greetings the moment we walked in and appreciative farewells on the way out. We had reservations for a high top table but chose to sit at the bar instead. We both chose to try the special, which was ... read more
Sue Farhoud via google.com - Nov 13, 2021
Outstanding meal and service in a very pleasant atmosphere. The owners had hosted a party for us a few years ago so we knew it'd be good. We had the tater tots, Caesar salad, yellowfin special and scallops and loved all of them. Not a lot of exotic fussy molecular gastronomy stuff, mostly familiar dishes done in a very creative way.
dhstlmo via google.com - Nov 6, 2021
Timothy's is the trifecta of dining... great atmosphere, wonderful, creative food, and excellent servers. You won't go wrong dining here!
Bruce Shoults via google.com - Nov 4, 2021
This place has some of the best comfort food around. 10/10, will definitely be coming back.
Janice Clayton via google.com - Nov 4, 2021
Love the decor and atmosphere. I wanted so many menu items because everything looked good. Had a short rib special with sweet potato mash and it was fantastic. Flatbread and deviled eggs were great, too. Nice cocktails, as well. Well taken care of by servers and owners! Will be back. Thanks!
Matthew Mattox via google.com - Nov 4, 2021
Went to Timothy's for the first time Saturday night. Decent restaurant with well prepared food. It was crowded and completely full even at 8:30pm when we left. The stars were the fried oysters, scallops and carrot cake fritters, didn't love the sirloin, sauce good but tough cut and the lobster pot pie was super rich, only enjoye ... read more
Andy Kohn via google.com - Oct 28, 2021
This new restaurant is absolutely amazing. It is officially my favorite restaurant in Saint Louis. My fiance and I went there for my birthday dinner and could not have had a better experience!! We started with the mussels, which reminded me of a trip to Thailand with the best broth! I could have picked up the bowl and drank the brot ... read more
Storm Vollertsen via google.com - Oct 28, 2021
Delicious food and great service. Cannot wait to come back again.
Richard Fisher via google.com - Oct 11, 2021
Timothy's restaurant is a must for dining out. The food is excellent, the chef is top notch, and the mixologist is a master! I had the ratatouille and beet salad at our most recent visit. The ratatouille entree was one of the best I've tasted.
Shelley Miana via google.com - Oct 11, 2021
Thrilled to have this little gem in the neighborhood! We tried Timothy's this weekend for the first time. We were greeted by a cozy yet upscale interior and warm, friendly staff. We grabbed a drink at the bar before being seated. I'll certainly be back for a cocktail in their bar. Dinner was delicious. Our server, Brandon, was knowl ... read more
Nora Black via google.com - Oct 11, 2021
Very nice new restaurant. The drinks were great and the lobster pot pie is incredible ... read more
ben reznikov via google.com - Oct 11, 2021
The ambience, the food, the service, the drinks...all elevated and well beyond what I had expected. Everything I had, from the deviled eggs to the surf & turf to the espressos martiini and carrot cake bites, was amazing. The tater tots are deluxe! I felt like I was a part of the family. Bravo to the team!
David Bolus via google.com - Oct 11, 2021
I can't write enough good things about Timothy's. The service was impeccable and the food was divine (our group had the filet, grilled caesar salad, beet salad, lobster pot pie, key lime creme brûlée and carrot cake fritters). As unbelievable as the food was, the service is what sets this place apart. Go there - you'll be treated lik ... read more
Paul Beuttenmuller via google.com - Oct 11, 2021
Beautiful space with amazing food and service. Lobster pot pie, burger, deviled eggs and the lamb were some of my favorites although everything I had was excellent. Service is top notch-professional and friendly. Cocktail list is innovative and the wine list is very expansive yet reasonably priced. Highly recommend!
Amanda Wilgus via google.com - Oct 11, 2021
Timothy’s was an A+ experience from the time we entered to the time we left. Though clearly an upscale space, we were warmly and unpretentiously greeted and treated cordially by every employee with whom we came in contact. (This is rare enough in the restaurant industry, but especially unexpected in the present pandemic, which has ... read more
N S via google.com - Oct 11, 2021
Pretty awesome to have this upscale little spot open up right by me. Would have to see how they manage a full-blown dinner rush, but the friendly service I got was outstanding! They had some trendy plates and an overall interesting menu. I definitely left feeling full and satisfied, yet I hadn't put myself into debt doing it. Only ... read more
Tony Cervellione via google.com - Oct 11, 2021
Timothy's was amazing. The food was delicious and the service was the best service I have had in a very long time. I will definitely be going back and recommending it to all of my friends!
Christy Koenemann via google.com - Oct 11, 2021
The best food and cocktail selections, the best service and AMAZING atmosphere. I can’t wait to try everything on their menu! 10/10 stars!
Madison McCracken via google.com - Sep 11, 2021
One of the best places to have dinner in STL. Great food and great service. Cannot wait to come back again. The Mac and cheese with lobster is amazing, also their tater tots with curry ketchup.
Jesús Alberto Ridaura Echeverría via google.com - Sep 11, 2021
So excited to return soon and try even more menu items! Our group all ordered something different including drinks and everyone was raving! The wine selection was great and reasonably priced and the food was amazing! You can tell they know what people want or introduce you to something you didn’t even know you needed in your life lik ... read more
Melissa Cline via google.com - Sep 11, 2021
I met the owners a week before they opened and they happen to be the nicest people ever. They really made me feel at home while they gave me a walk around the place..
Craig Currie via google.com - Aug 11, 2021
To say my fiancé and I had the best experience would be an understatement. The restaurant is gorgeous! A beautiful mix of cozy & trendy. The service was amazing! Our waitstaff was attentive, friendly, and made our experience fun. The food though. Y’all. It.was.life.changing!!! My fiancé and I were the quietest we’ve ever been other t ... read more
Stacy Tolliver via google.com - Aug 11, 2021
We were so excited to be a part of Timothy’s soft opening! This place is fantastic, a great ambiance, perfect location and artisan food that won’t disappoint. The service was excellent and we had a great dining experience. I think one of the best parts of our first experience at Timothy’s was it feels like a shared family dining e ... read more
Steve Georgevitch via google.com - Aug 11, 2021
I was fortunate enough to attend the Tues soft opening. My dining experience was excellent. My dinner was fantabulous and delectably delicious- all three courses. I would highly recommend Timothy's to anyone who loves delicious food and an atmosphere of complete ambiance. Five stars are not a high enough rating.
James Metz, Sr. via google.com - Aug 11, 2021
I went to the soft opening and let me say you won’t be disappointed! The food was amazing and please be sure you try the sweet potato lemonade as it was divine. The service and Decor was amazing. I had the burger and Mac n cheese with a chocolate chip cookie with ice cream. All the food was amazing ans I can’t wait to go back.
Amanda miller via google.com - Aug 11, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire