skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Excellent! Food was fabulous and service outstanding! Will go back and definitely recommend.
Excellent! Food was fabulous and service outstanding! Will go back and definitely recommend.
Maryanne G. via yelp.com - May 16, 2022
Food was delicious, great service, outstanding service, great addition to Creve Couer. Will be back!
Anna Martin via google.com - May 14, 2022
Awesome food with great service. Exactly what I look for in a restaurant. Great culinary experience
Awesome food with great service. Exactly what I look for in a restaurant. Great culinary experience !
Sam O. via yelp.com - May 6, 2022
Absolutely amazing! One of my favorites! I moved to St Louis and am so happy I found Timothy's!
Absolutely amazing! One of my favorites! I moved to St Louis and am so happy I found Timothy's!
Greg C. via yelp.com - May 1, 2022
We had a date night at Timothy's and everything was top notch. The service was impeccable. Our favor
We had a date night at Timothy's and everything was top notch. The service was impeccable. Our favorite bites were the grilled Caesar salad with anchovies and the lamb with chimichurri sauce. The lamb was so tender! We look forward to going back and are thrilled to have such a wonderful restaurant right next to our neighborhood.
S. S. via yelp.com - Apr 30, 2022
Second visit! Did not disappoint! My favorite thing about going out for date night is consistency, i
Second visit! Did not disappoint! My favorite thing about going out for date night is consistency, if I pick a location, I want to know everything is going to be AS good as it was the time before. We brought couple friends with us last night and they loved their entree choices also. We started with the lobster pot pie, our friends lo ... read more
Mindy P. via yelp.com - Apr 24, 2022
Food is wonderful, wine selection and cocktails terrific, service is prompt and friendly. I do love
Food is wonderful, wine selection and cocktails terrific, service is prompt and friendly. I do love the bar area but dining room is also perfect. It has become a favorite for us!
Nancy T. via yelp.com - Apr 21, 2022
Our first time here. Food was good. Way too noisy for conversation. Bread pudding was not to my liki
Our first time here. Food was good. Way too noisy for conversation. Bread pudding was not to my liking.
Ann F. via yelp.com - Apr 20, 2022
Great little hideaway. This place has an old club bar feel to it. It's in a strip mall but once insi
Great little hideaway. This place has an old club bar feel to it. It's in a strip mall but once inside you turn your attention to a simple menu of well constructed and well presented dishes that are outrageously good. To note, the Lobster Pock Pie App is out of this world. The escargot- terrific. Mussels-excellent. Dessert carrot cak ... read more
Max M. via yelp.com - Apr 19, 2022
Professional service, friendly and down to earth. Especially relaxing on a Monday night so we had a
Professional service, friendly and down to earth. Especially relaxing on a Monday night so we had a lovely evening. Tender and delicious lamb chops with sauces subtle but perfect. Veggies warm drizzled in olive oil. Wife had steak frites that were excellent. Crunchy frites!! A small dessert complementary on her birthday was classy. E ... read more
ED S. via yelp.com - Apr 18, 2022
Absolutely amazing from start to finish. Very reasonably priced. 2 x (apps entrees deserts and 1 bot
Absolutely amazing from start to finish. Very reasonably priced. 2 x (apps entrees deserts and 1 bottle of Syrah) under $200 ... read more
James J. via yelp.com - Apr 18, 2022
Great service. Friendly owners. Thoroughly enjoyed the meal. We heard about the place and are so gla
Great service. Friendly owners. Thoroughly enjoyed the meal. We heard about the place and are so glad we came. It was my birthday dinner.
Daniel O. via yelp.com - Apr 14, 2022
Great food in an intimate atmosphere with a wonderful wine list and exceptional service!
Great food in an intimate atmosphere with a wonderful wine list and exceptional service!
Phil T. via yelp.com - Apr 12, 2022
Highly recommend for food, atmosphere & service. Great location, very nice bar, excellent food!
Highly recommend for food, atmosphere & service. Great location, very nice bar, excellent food!
Matt M. via yelp.com - Apr 6, 2022
What a phenomenal meal. We decided to spend out 25th anniversary here versus our favorites of Paul Manno's or Napoli 2. And what a wonderful treat. Service was spectacular. Food was wonderful and even the mixologist was incredible. If I had complaint it would be lack of options but everything we had was superb. You need to try this ... read more
Michael Oliver via google.com - Apr 5, 2022
Excellent meal. The food menu only has a 1/2 dozen or so entrees but they are very good to excellent. In comparison, the wine menu is quite extensive. However, the service is what really stands out, very old-school. Your water glass will never be empty and the wait staff anticipates your every request. When so many restaurants are st ... read more
McLeod Patton via google.com - Mar 28, 2022
This is one of our favorite places to go. You can't go wrong with any choice on the menu. Every time we've gone the food has been exactly the same and the service is fantastic.
Cathy Wilson via google.com - Mar 28, 2022
First time visit last week; we were in the mood for a really nice restaurant. Timothy's delivered fo
First time visit last week; we were in the mood for a really nice restaurant. Timothy's delivered for sure! The service was excellent, and that's saying a lot in this post-pandemic shortage. We had the Dover sole special, beautifully prepared table side, and the ratatouille--delicious. Fabulous key lime creme brûlée for dessert. High ... read more
Ellen L. via yelp.com - Mar 27, 2022
Delicious food, great upscale but casual atmosphere and wonderful, attentive service. We will be back!
Jennifer Vehige via google.com - Mar 19, 2022
Went to Timothy's for a date night and it was so much fun. The food and customer service is amazing.
Went to Timothy's for a date night and it was so much fun. The food and customer service is amazing. We were seated by one of the co-owners (I only knew this because I recently read the stl magazine article on the resultant) and our waitress was delightful. The Mussels appetizer was our personal favorite. The sauce is delicious and I ... read more
Maja R. via yelp.com - Mar 19, 2022
We went to Timothy's for a birthday dinner. It was our first time. It was good but my expectations w
We went to Timothy's for a birthday dinner. It was our first time. It was good but my expectations were too high from all the goos reviews posted. The presentation of the meals could of been better for the price tags. I wish the atmosphere was nicer and the service was less uptight and unfriendly. We may be go back just to give it an ... read more
Trina L. via yelp.com - Mar 15, 2022
Delicious! Very nice, new place. Great atmosphere, wonderful food and attentive waitstaff.
Delicious! Very nice, new place. Great atmosphere, wonderful food and attentive waitstaff.
Skyler C. via yelp.com - Mar 15, 2022
One of the best additions to this part of STL county in a long time. We went the Saturday before Valentine's Day and had superb food and drinks. Lobster Pot Pie appetizer was delicious. Wife had the lobster bisque and lobster/crab cakes...both were specials for the holiday and both were phenomenal. I had the brussel sprout salad and ... read more
Patrick Gebhard via google.com - Mar 13, 2022
Spectacular date night tonight at Timothy's! It was our first time and we really loved this place st
Spectacular date night tonight at Timothy's! It was our first time and we really loved this place start to finish. It was quite an experience. Attention to detail by the servers was top notch. As we were seated, my wife made a remark to me about having forgotten her cheater glasses so she could read the menu. I kid you not, the host ... read more
Gary R. via yelp.com - Mar 12, 2022
Good mc&cheese, variety of GF dishes, awesome service, enjoyable atmosphere,.. unfortunately, the carrot cake fritters has a horrible aftertaste and the cook doesn’t listen to requests.. so my “no hot spices” wasn’t followed and I couldn’t enjoy my plate.
Dr Bubu via google.com - Mar 6, 2022
What a great atmosphere and super delicious food. I ordered and loved the deviled eggs, house salad
What a great atmosphere and super delicious food. I ordered and loved the deviled eggs, house salad and chicken. I'll be back next week!
Cindy H. via yelp.com - Mar 4, 2022
Great evening at Timothy's! First class service from the minute we walked in the door, Love what the
Great evening at Timothy's! First class service from the minute we walked in the door, Love what the owners did with the space. Everyone was friendly, drinks and food were top notch, and Jordan is the bomb! Will definitely go back soon.
Lesley H. via yelp.com - Mar 2, 2022
Incredible food and the wine selection is fantastic. The best creme brulee in St. Louis!
David Toole via google.com - Feb 28, 2022
Outstanding food and great service!!! This was my first visit to Timothy's. Can't wait to go back!
Outstanding food and great service!!! This was my first visit to Timothy's. Can't wait to go back!
C P. via yelp.com - Feb 28, 2022
Phenomenal. The ambiance, the service, the food, all were great. For our first time dining here we w
Phenomenal. The ambiance, the service, the food, all were great. For our first time dining here we were thoroughly impressed and I'm already ready to go back. We got the house salad, the filet, and the truffle Mac and cheese. So delish. That salad is one of my absolute favorites. 12/10 recommend.
Kaley B. via yelp.com - Feb 26, 2022
Fantastic food and lovely experience! We sat at the bar for a quick bite and were greeted with frien
Fantastic food and lovely experience! We sat at the bar for a quick bite and were greeted with friendly staff and good food and wine. The scallop special is amazing. Please try this little gem!
Lauralyn F. via yelp.com - Feb 25, 2022
Food was incredible. Service a little slow. Th I s is a sit talk and enjoy the food, wine and I wonderful cocktail ... read more
Ken Ritch via google.com - Feb 19, 2022
It is a small cozy restaurant tucked away in Bellrieve Plaza it was quiet when I was there. We were supposed to get ice. I tried the bruschetta as an appetizer snd the Lobster pot pie for main course. Both were delicious. My friend had the beef tenderloin special snd a beet salad. He loved both. Some of my family has als ... read more
Katie N via google.com - Feb 19, 2022
This was our first time at Timothy's and we enjoyed it very much. The service was very good, the win
This was our first time at Timothy's and we enjoyed it very much. The service was very good, the wine selection was outstanding with good prices and the food was very good. A nice neighborhood gem. I'll go back.
Julie P. via yelp.com - Feb 19, 2022
This was a new spot for me and it did not disappoint. The Filet was cooked to perfection and at an a
This was a new spot for me and it did not disappoint. The Filet was cooked to perfection and at an affordable price. I was a single traveling in town and so called ahead to see if they could seat me. Upon arrival, one waiter wasn't going to seat me and the bar area was full. I waited for another waiter and he gave me the corner #1 bo ... read more
Mark R. via yelp.com - Feb 17, 2022
One of the best dining experiences my husband and I have had in a few years. We interacted with a lot of staff (host, bartender, manager/Sommelier, server), and everyone was so warm and welcoming and excited to be at work that night. The wine program is very nice and run by someone who knows how to spot a gem, and orders special beve ... read more
Julia Greco via google.com - Feb 15, 2022
I had my 80th, birthday dinner there last Friday night. The food was wonderful and the service was outstanding. It was a great pleasure to watch a well trained and experienced staff at work. I thank them all for making my 80th. a great night.
Lenard Voelker via google.com - Feb 14, 2022
My wife and I live very close to this gem and were lucky enough to discover it late last year. Every time we've visited we've had an incredible experience, from service, to the delicious food and drinks. Do yourself a favor and get a few starters (including the Fontina tots with the curry ketchup) and a salad, as well as an entrée. ... read more
Joseph M via google.com - Feb 7, 2022
We select Timothy's for significant family events. Their food and staff are great!. We are always ha
We select Timothy's for significant family events. Their food and staff are great!. We are always happy we went to Timothy's regardless of the occasion. I personally like their beet salad and Mac 'b Cheese with lobster both of which are delicious and reasonably priced.
Dick S. via yelp.com - Feb 4, 2022
Timothy"s is one of our new favorites. The food is always great as well as the cocktails. The wait s
Timothy"s is one of our new favorites. The food is always great as well as the cocktails. The wait staff is excellent and very friendly.
Dawn K. via yelp.com - Feb 2, 2022
Excellent food and wine selection Something for everyone Soup, salad and burger were outstanding ... read more
Jim George via google.com - Jan 26, 2022
Probably the best service I've ever received in my life. We went for my husbands birthday, staff was
Probably the best service I've ever received in my life. We went for my husbands birthday, staff was knowledgeable about the wine and recommended a bottle of cab that was exactly what we were looking for. We split the vegetable flatbread which was delicious, and split the grilled Caesar salad which was also fantastic - and I really a ... read more
Betsy B. via yelp.com - Jan 26, 2022
I have already recommended Timothy's to several people. We had the lobster pot pie, Brussels sprout
I have already recommended Timothy's to several people. We had the lobster pot pie, Brussels sprout salad, lobster Mac n cheese, surf and turf special. All excellent!! The beet salad was good overall. Though the beets were too firm, the goat cheese was amazing. I would order again. The carrot cake donuts are a must!! The key lime cre ... read more
Michele B. via yelp.com - Jan 23, 2022
Service was excellent. Cocktails were very good. We found the food bland. Descriptions were creative
Service was excellent. Cocktails were very good. We found the food bland. Descriptions were creative and the staff did a great job of selling but the taste did not match up. It was good for a date night.
Lisa M. via yelp.com - Jan 22, 2022
I thoroughly enjoyed my dining experience at Timothys My husband and I had the sirloin special which came with risotto and asparagus with a hollandaise sauce on the side. We started with the mussels which came in a very appetizing sauce. Next we had the charred Caesar salad which was excellent. All the servings came out timely which ... read more
Denise Porter via google.com - Jan 19, 2022
Amazing! Definitely a must try and living in this area it's a great addition to our community. The food, cocktails and wine are phenomenal and they treat you like family!
Shannon Armstrong via google.com - Jan 18, 2022
First time. Very happy with the choice. Will add Timothy’s to our rotation. Steaks + Good wine selection ... read more
Robert Guimbarda via google.com - Jan 14, 2022
Beautiful setting and excellent food and cocktail selections. I will be returning soon.
Beautiful setting and excellent food and cocktail selections. I will be returning soon.
Gina B. via yelp.com - Jan 8, 2022
I love that one of St. Louis's best restaurants is within a mile from my home. I will be making my f
I love that one of St. Louis's best restaurants is within a mile from my home. I will be making my fourth visit in as many months. The cuisine is quite suprisingly out of the ordinary! Try everything on the menu... it's all scrumptuous! Book a large table and share the food and fun. Timothy's has a great, friendly vibe. Servers add t ... read more
Caroline M. via yelp.com - Dec 28, 2021
Such a great addition to the Creve Coeur. The menu is eclectic and has something for everyone. Friendly staff and the owners are just lovely. Get the lobster pot pie for an app and the Carrot Cake Fritters for dessert (change your life good)!
Blake Moroni via google.com - Dec 25, 2021
I don't think I could have picked a better place for our Christmas dinner this year. Ambiance = chec
I don't think I could have picked a better place for our Christmas dinner this year. Ambiance = check. Delicious food = check. Superb service = check. The trifecta of a perfect dining experience. Timothy's is nestled within a shopping/dining area on Olive and we weren't even quite sure we turned the right way were it not for trusting ... read more
Mel A. via yelp.com - Dec 24, 2021
Lobster pot pie was very rich and decadent. Has that as entree with side of veg. There menu could us
Lobster pot pie was very rich and decadent. Has that as entree with side of veg. There menu could use more variety but everything we had was delicious.
Elizabeth L. via yelp.com - Dec 22, 2021
The best service we've ever had! The drinks at the bar prior to dinner (hot toddys) were so delish!
The best service we've ever had! The drinks at the bar prior to dinner (hot toddys) were so delish! And the food was outstanding! Can't wait to go back! Brandon, our server, was the best, as was Joe at the bar! We stayed about 3 hours at this place!
Lela A. via yelp.com - Dec 22, 2021
An amazing dining experience. Lobster Pot Pie, surf n turf, and carrot cake fritters for dessert! Excellent service, check out this gem!
Nicole Christ via google.com - Dec 21, 2021
Super cute little restaurant with very delicious food! Service was amazing! The key lime brûlée was
Super cute little restaurant with very delicious food! Service was amazing! The key lime brûlée was my favorite and it's a must!
Courtney C. via yelp.com - Dec 17, 2021
Quaint little restaurant where you can go for an elegant dinner. The dinner service is impeccable. W
Quaint little restaurant where you can go for an elegant dinner. The dinner service is impeccable. We started off with salads. My wife had their house and I had the grilled ceasar. My only criticism of the grilled ceasar was that it was not shocked in cold water after being grilled as you could really taste the char. The dressing was ... read more
Dawn H. via yelp.com - Dec 16, 2021
Quaint little restaurant where you can go for an elegant dinner. The dinner service is impeccable. We started off with salads. My wife had their house and I had the grilled ceasar. My only criticism of the grilled ceasar was that it was not shocked in cold water after being grilled as you could really taste the char. The dressing w ... read more
Dawn Held via google.com - Dec 15, 2021
This is a new exciting restaurant in Creve Coeur. I seriously wanted to order everything on the menu
This is a new exciting restaurant in Creve Coeur. I seriously wanted to order everything on the menu. I had the Butternut squash soup along with the salmon which was fantastic. I also had a great Espresso martini. The ambiance was really good. They took a familiar building and made it fresh. I can't wait to go back and have dinner ag ... read more
Jason O. via yelp.com - Dec 14, 2021
Good food and location. Not the fastest nor most attentive service.
Michael Kneznekoff via google.com - Dec 13, 2021
I would classify Timothy's as a hidden gem. It is also a first for me, as this was my initial experi
I would classify Timothy's as a hidden gem. It is also a first for me, as this was my initial experience making a reservation on yelp, confirming it, and ultimately using the platform to share a review. Talk about a one-stop shop! The newly opened Timothy's restaurant brings timeless fine dining to Creve Coeur. Before going to the re ... read more
Shanti N. via yelp.com - Dec 13, 2021
We went here for our supper club and we all enjoyed it. From wonderful burger to a filet, everything was good. Cocktails were nice as well. The amosphere was great also.
Gregory Forck via google.com - Dec 10, 2021
We love this place! The Lobster Pot Pie was delicious, the deviled eggs were excellent and our entrees were all wonderful, especially the Airline Chicken and Lobster Mac and Cheese. Timothy’s has a very retro, super club vibe in a beautiful space. We will be back.
Gina Sigillito via google.com - Dec 9, 2021
The service was fantastic, our waiyer was very attractive. The busboy was fantastic, my water never emptied. The food was not quite what I expected. The salad was very tasty, my scallops were luke warm the steak was tough. I ordered there special Surf and Turf. The steak was cool I ordered medium and it came out right color but it wa ... read more
Patty Desrosiers via google.com - Dec 4, 2021
I like this restaurant and would go back bottom line. It is relatively affordable for a nice dinner.
I like this restaurant and would go back bottom line. It is relatively affordable for a nice dinner. I will mention that the majority of the staff were not adhering to covid precautions and didn't have masks. Our server did have a mask and I thanked her for wearing one and she did the same, probably one of the few reasons I will leav ... read more
Una M. via yelp.com - Dec 4, 2021
We have been coming here since they opened. There food is excellent! They have an incredible staff a
We have been coming here since they opened. There food is excellent! They have an incredible staff and their Chef delivers the food to your table. Sometimes the dinning room can be loud. A hidden gem!
Stephanie F. via yelp.com - Nov 30, 2021
The best restaurant in the STL area for all you foodies out there! Some of the best food we have eve
The best restaurant in the STL area for all you foodies out there! Some of the best food we have ever had- complements to the chef!
Natalie S. via yelp.com - Nov 27, 2021
My family members had been here before and said great things. The servers and service was phenomenal
My family members had been here before and said great things. The servers and service was phenomenal the entire night. The restaurant has a modern/clean ambiance and an interesting menu. They have many dishes that cater to a gluten free or vegan diet, and are delicious! The mussel appetizer was in the most amazing broth, but the lobs ... read more
Rosie C. via yelp.com - Nov 18, 2021
Incredible food, upscale and beautiful setting with outstanding staff especially Brandon.
Incredible food, upscale and beautiful setting with outstanding staff especially Brandon.
George V. via yelp.com - Nov 15, 2021
My boyfriend and I were looking to try something new. It was our first time at Timothy’s and we were not disappointed! We received warm greetings the moment we walked in and appreciative farewells on the way out. We had reservations for a high top table but chose to sit at the bar instead. We both chose to try the special, which was ... read more
Sue Farhoud via google.com - Nov 13, 2021
Flawless from start to finish. The evening was exceptional - service, presentation, food, drinks - p
Flawless from start to finish. The evening was exceptional - service, presentation, food, drinks - perfection! Try the house margarita - I don't even like margaritas but this was a great interpretation. Deviled eggs, fontina tater tots - amazing. Our table had 3 different salads - all amazing. Entrees - steaks, scallops, and the tuna ... read more
Amy S. via yelp.com - Nov 7, 2021
Outstanding meal and service in a very pleasant atmosphere. The owners had hosted a party for us a few years ago so we knew it'd be good. We had the tater tots, Caesar salad, yellowfin special and scallops and loved all of them. Not a lot of exotic fussy molecular gastronomy stuff, mostly familiar dishes done in a very creative way.
dhstlmo via google.com - Nov 6, 2021
Love the decor and atmosphere. I wanted so many menu items because everything looked good. Had a short rib special with sweet potato mash and it was fantastic. Flatbread and deviled eggs were great, too. Nice cocktails, as well. Well taken care of by servers and owners! Will be back. Thanks!
Matthew Mattox via google.com - Nov 4, 2021
Timothy's is the trifecta of dining... great atmosphere, wonderful, creative food, and excellent servers. You won't go wrong dining here!
Bruce Shoults via google.com - Nov 4, 2021
This place has some of the best comfort food around. 10/10, will definitely be coming back.
Janice Clayton via google.com - Nov 4, 2021
We had a great dining experience. We had a group of 7 of us and were seating in one of the banquette
We had a great dining experience. We had a group of 7 of us and were seating in one of the banquettes in the bar area. It was a fun area to be able to have a good conversation but also feel the energy of the restaurant. Our waiter Steve was excellent and gave us great suggestions all night. I started with the grilled Caesar salad whi ... read more
Rob R. via yelp.com - Nov 1, 2021
Went to Timothy's for the first time Saturday night. Decent restaurant with well prepared food. It was crowded and completely full even at 8:30pm when we left. The stars were the fried oysters, scallops and carrot cake fritters, didn't love the sirloin, sauce good but tough cut and the lobster pot pie was super rich, only enjoye ... read more
Andy Kohn via google.com - Oct 28, 2021
This new restaurant is absolutely amazing. It is officially my favorite restaurant in Saint Louis. My fiance and I went there for my birthday dinner and could not have had a better experience!! We started with the mussels, which reminded me of a trip to Thailand with the best broth! I could have picked up the bowl and drank the brot ... read more
Storm Vollertsen via google.com - Oct 28, 2021
What a pleasant little surprise! The food was exceptional, the drinks were well mixed and the servic
What a pleasant little surprise! The food was exceptional, the drinks were well mixed and the service was spectacular. My only regret is that there are so many more items on the menu that I'd like to try so I'll just have to go back. Perfect spot for a date night: cloth table linens, dim lighting without being too dark, quiet but not ... read more
Jan R. via yelp.com - Oct 25, 2021
Lovely place! Extremely pleased with the service, here. My date got the chicken brest entree. The ca
Lovely place! Extremely pleased with the service, here. My date got the chicken brest entree. The cauliflower that it came with was very good. I opted for the ceasar salad. And an extra side of the veggies. Needless to say, I had leftovers, lol. It was all so delicious. The veggies were seasoned perfectly. Not too mushy or raw. The a ... read more
Harla R. via yelp.com - Oct 23, 2021
Fantastic food, service and atmosphere! Great addition to the St. Louis fine dining scene.
Fantastic food, service and atmosphere! Great addition to the St. Louis fine dining scene.
Paul M. via yelp.com - Oct 21, 2021
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire